12 Comments
User's avatar
Liz's avatar

I have accumulated a lot of American culture critics on my tl and its always weird to see their subtle, clever, funny takes on the US juxtaposed with total ignorance of UK stuff, and especially royalty. Someone was v. perturbed that Kate signed her tweet with a C rather than a K, another was sure the royals had a crack team of photo manipulators on call, and they probably didn't even have computers in Windsor. It's been fun though.

Expand full comment
Sarah Harkness's avatar

Delighted to read the Stock article, which I would otherwise have missed. I had never heard of Judith Butler til my daughter brought one of her books home from an EngLit course at UEA. Oh how we laughed.

Expand full comment
Helen Lewis's avatar

Sarah Ditum also wrote a review in the Times which is great, though paywalled.

Expand full comment
Sarah Harkness's avatar

Found it, thank you. Also excellent! 'Most humanities academics deal principally in language, and the more power language is supposed to have, the more powerful they get to feel.'

Expand full comment
helena's avatar

irl lol at "sloppy liberal who bangs on about free speech and evidence when there's a sexy revolution happening"

Expand full comment
Caroline Charles's avatar

I just read that Andrea Long Chu article and I'm pretty sure I just felt my soul erode.

Expand full comment
Peter Krijgsman's avatar

I read that headline as Habsburg AL rather than AI (the distinction only works with capitals) which gave the whole disruptor class a pleasing junior, burger-glutton gangster persona, about to get dumped in the north river. But I guess AI is better, especially as there is no AL in the story.

Expand full comment
Lee Ward's avatar

I remember reading a long Nicole Cliffe newsletter pre-pandemic all about the cause de Cholmondeley, and thinking it was the barmiest thing I'd ever read.... now, I wonder

Expand full comment
Charles Arthur's avatar

Kathleen Stock’s review of Butler’s book is quite the treat. And a hell of a contrast with the Guardian review by someone who obediently uses “they” but isn’t a good enough writer to always disambiguate whether the “they” in question are the one or the many. (Like the Dave Chapelle joke, I suppose.)

Gdn review: https://www.theguardian.com/books/2024/mar/13/whos-afraid-of-gender-by-judith-butler-review-the-gender-theorist-goes-mainstream

Expand full comment
Jo Candiano's avatar

But what *has* happened to the princess?

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Mar 15, 2024
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
Helen Lewis's avatar

Thanks for reading so closely! My keyboard has finally given up (too many lunches eaten over it, I suspect) but I’m getting a new one, which should sort the problem.

Expand full comment
Jason Ramasami's avatar

I have deleted my comment because the world doesn't need another nit picker gathering crust.

Expand full comment